Bit ValueValue, taken apart without the safari.

Why ETH Burns Alone Cannot Anchor a Valuation

Originally published November 11, 2026, at 11:03 (UTC+8), by Biteye via PANews. The figures below reflect the periods described in that article, not current measurements.

On November 8, Vitalik Buterin revisited the sources of ETH’s value in a post on X. His challenge to the “ultrasound money” argument was not that fee burning has no effect on supply. It was that burns driven partly by speculative activity cannot be treated as a dependable valuation floor. He supported retaining EIP-1559, but argued that even if future burns remain below 10% of new issuance, pursuing higher fees merely to increase burns could harm Ethereum’s decentralization and long-term development.

Supply changes are not the same across chains

Biteye’s comparison shows why a burn figure needs to be read alongside issuance, unlocks and the rules governing fees:

  • BTC: Its supply cap is approximately 21 million coins. At 3.125 BTC per block and an assumed average of one block every ten minutes, Biteye estimated roughly 164,300 new BTC a year and annual supply inflation of about 0.82%. Block rewards halve approximately every four years.
  • ETH: Following The Merge in 2022, cumulative supply growth was about 1.37% as reported in the article. EIP-1559 burns base fees, but over the 30-day period cited by Biteye, burns offset only about 3.2% of new issuance amid wider L2 use and lower gas fees.
  • SOL: Solana’s initial annual inflation rate was 8%, with a scheduled 15% yearly reduction toward a long-term 1.5% rate. Daily burns exceeded 10,000 SOL at one point during the 2024 meme-coin boom, and burns offset about 23% of issuance in January 2025. After SIMD-0096 directed all priority fees to validators while retaining a burn of 50% of base fees, daily burns at one point fell to roughly 700 SOL.
  • BNB: Rather than relying on continuing issuance, BNB reduces supply through quarterly Auto-Burn and BEP-95 gas-fee burns, toward a target supply of 100 million. Biteye reported that the first four quarterly burns of 2026 totaled about 6.2 million BNB. Auto-Burn depends on price and block production; BEP-95 burns a portion of network fees.
  • TRX: TRON issues block rewards and burns fees paid for Energy and Bandwidth. Because users can also obtain those resources by staking or renting them, more USDT transfers do not necessarily mean proportionally more TRX burned.
  • AVAX: Its supply cap is 720 million. Validator rewards add supply, while fees on the primary network’s X-, C- and P-chains are burned. By early November 2026, Biteye reported about 474 million AVAX minted, including roughly 114 million in staking rewards, against approximately 5.18 million burned cumulatively.
  • SUI: Its total supply is fixed at 10 billion; unlocks are a key source of growth in circulating supply. The Storage Fund locks some storage fees and uses staking returns to compensate validators. Most fees can be recovered when data is deleted, while the unrecovered portion stays in the fund rather than being permanently burned.
Why ETH Burns Alone Cannot Anchor a Valuation

What a burn-based valuation assumes

The model Buterin discussed can be written as token valuation = annual dollar value of burns ÷ discount rate. If a chain reliably burned $1 billion of tokens every year, a 4% discount rate would imply $25 billion under that model. The word reliably does much of the work: the calculation assumes a continuing burn stream and does not, by itself, establish a market-value floor.

Biteye reported that Ethereum burned approximately 1.48 million ETH, worth about $3.6 billion, in 2022. From the start of 2026 through November 8, it reported about 19,200 ETH burned, worth roughly $43 million. Using the article’s simplified annualized estimate of around $50 million and the same 4% rate produces a model value of about $1.25 billion. Biteye contrasted that with an ETH market capitalization of approximately $270 billion at the time—a gap of more than 200 times. The comparison exposes the model’s limits; it does not show that either figure is a fair-value estimate.

Burns capture only one route by which network activity may distribute economic value. Solana priority fees go to validators, while TRON resource rentals may benefit stakers; neither flow appears wholly in token burns. Nor does activity automatically become protocol revenue or value accruing to every token holder.

For ETH, the article also considers demand as on-chain collateral, a medium of exchange and a native asset of financial infrastructure. Buterin emphasized decentralization, censorship resistance, open source, privacy and security, particularly as AI develops. Those qualities may support demand, but the monetary premium attributed to them is harder to measure than fees. ETH also has no fixed supply cap, and its issuance rules can change through protocol upgrades. A valuation argument therefore has to state both its demand assumptions and why holders would trust the supply rules over time—not substitute a single burn multiple for either question.

Source: panewslab.com (originally published 2026-11-11 11:03 UTC+8)